Technology of Digital Maturity Estimation for an Educational Organization. Part II

We present the developed system of estimating the digital maturity of an educational organization. The objective of estimating digital maturity has been formalized thanks to analyzing the existing approaches to validation of the digital maturity for an organizational object. The novelty of the given study is in introducing the fuzzy mechanism of integral estimation calculation of digital maturity into the digital maturity evaluation methodology. The methods of expert estimation, discrete mathematics and fuzzy logical inference were used to create the model. The utilization of the model developed is demonstrated on the example of higher education in the Russian Federation. The technique is adaptive and can be applied not only in educational organizations but also in organizations in other spheres of activity.

1. Kanev V. S., Poletaykin A. N., Shevtsova Yu. V. Tekhnologiya otsenivaniya tsifrovoy zrelosti obrazovatelnoy organizatsii. Chast I [Technology of digital maturity estimation for an educational organization. Part I]. Vestnik SibGUTI, 2021, no. №3 (55), pp. 63-76.

2. Ifenthaler D., Egloffstein M. Development and Implementation of a Maturity Model of Digital Transformation. TechTrends, 2020, no. 64, pp. 302-309, available at: https://ifenthaler.info/website/?p=572 (accessed: 22.03.2022).

3. Begičević Ređep N., Klačmer Čalopa M., Tomičić Pupek K. The Challenge of Digital Transformation in European Education Systems. Educational Leadership, Improvement and Change, available at: https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-030-47020-3_8 (accessed: 22.03.2022).

4. Kashitsin V. P. Metodika audita tsifrovoy zrelosti organizatsiy srednego professionalnogo obrazovaniya [Methodology of auditing the digital maturity for organizations of secondary vocational education]. Vestnik nauki i obrazovaniya, 2021, no. 10-1(113), pp. 55-64.

5. Savvinov V. M., Ivanov P. P., Strekalovskiy V. N. Metody i printsipy otsenki tsifrovoy zrelosti obrazovatelnykh organizatsiy [Methods and principles of digital maturity estimation for educational organizations]. Vestnik SVFU im. M.K. Ammosova. Seriya «Pedagogika. Psikhologiya. Filosofiya», 2021, no. 2 (22), pp. 28-40.

6. Frantasov D. N., Balanovskaya A. V. Tsifrovaya zrelost kak osnova strategicheskogo razvitiya i tsifrovoy transformatsii obrazovatelnykh organizatsiy [Digital maturity as a basis for strategic development and digital transformation of educational organizations]. Vestnik Samarskogo gosudarstvennogo ekonomicheskogo universiteta, 2022, no. 2(208), pp. 57-64.

7. Shumakova O. V., Mozzherina T. G., Pomogaev V. M., Kryukova O. N. Strategiya tsifrovoy transformatsii universiteta: vyzovy i zadachi realizatsii [University digital transformation strategy: challenges and objectives]. Sbornik trudov vserossiyskoy nauchno-prakticheskoy konferentsii «Tsifrovizatsiya agrarnogo obrazovaniya: napravleniya, metody, instrument, 2022, pp. 112-122.

8. Pasport tsifrovoy zrelosti [Passport of digital maturity]. Institut tsifrovogo razvitiya nauki i obrazovaniya, available at: https://scieddi.vsite.biz, (accessed: 30.09.2022).

9. Otsenka tsifrovoy zrelosti [Digital maturity estimation]. Tsentr perspektivnykh upravlencheskikh resheniy, available at: https://cpur.ru/projects_inside-project_grading, (accessed: 30.09.2022).

10. Novikov D. A. Kibernetika: Navigator. Istoriya kibernetiki, sovremennoe sostoyanie, perspektivy razvitiya [Cybernetics: Navigator. History of cybernetics, current state, development prospects]. Moscow, LENAND, 2016. 160 p.

11. Strategiya tsifrovoy transformatsii otrasli nauki i vysshego obrazovaniya [Strategy of digital transformation for science and higher education]. Ofitsialnyy sayt Minobrnauki Rossii, available at: https://www.minobrnauki.gov.ru/documents/?ELEMENT_ID=36749, (accessed: 13.10.2022).

12. Shevtsova Yu. V., Danilova L. F., Poletaykin A. N., Monastyrskaya T. I. Matematicheskaya model nechetkogo otsenivaniya tsifrovoy zrelosti organizatsionnogo obekta [Mathematical model of fuzzy estimation of the digital maturity for an organizational object]. Materialy XVIII mezhdunarodnoy aziatskoy shkoly-seminara «Problemy optimizatsii slozhnykh system», 2022, pp. 5-16.

13. Kunts E. Yu., Poletaykin A. N., Shevtsova Yu. V. Realizatsiya modeli nechetkogo otsenivaniya sformirovannosti kompetentsiy s pomoshchyu paketa MATLAB [Implementation of a fuzzy estimation model for the formation of competencies by MATLAB]. Novye informatsionnye tekhnologii v obrazovanii i nauke, 2020, no. 3, pp. 66-72.

14. Kunts E. Yu., Poletaykin A. N., Dvurechenskaya N. A. Issledovanie dostovernosti nechetkoy modeli otsenivaniya rezultatov obucheniya [Study of the reliability of a fuzzy model for estimation learning results]. Vestnik SibGUTI, 2020, no. 4 (52), pp. 92-97.

15. Shevtsova Yu. V., Poletaykin A. N., Monastyrskaya T. I, Danilova L. F. Eksperimentalnoe otsenivanie tsifrovoy zrelosti podrazdeleniya SibGUTI [Experimental estimation of the digital maturity for the SibSUTIS`s department]. Materialy LХIII mezhvuzovskoy nauchno-metodicheskoy konferentsii «Aktualnye voprosy sovershenstvovaniya srednego professionalnogo i vysshego obrazovaniya v sovremennykh usloviyakh», 2022, pp. 176-182.